1031 exchanges · Failed exchanges
What happens if a 1031 exchange fails?
The short answer
A failed 1031 exchange generally means the transaction does not qualify for the intended tax deferral under Section 1031. The investor may have to recognize taxable gain from the sale of the relinquished property. The consequences depend on the transaction, amount of gain, and applicable tax rules.
Read the full answer ↓Why do 1031 exchanges fail?
A failed exchange does not automatically mean the investor loses the sale proceeds. It means the anticipated tax treatment may change.
Common reasons include:
- Missing the 45-day replacement-property identification deadline
- Failing to acquire replacement property within the exchange period
- Identifying properties that do not satisfy IRS requirements
- Taking actual or constructive receipt of exchange proceeds
- Acquiring property that does not qualify for like-kind treatment
The IRS Form 8824 instructions confirm that missing exchange timing requirements can cause a transaction to lose its deferred-exchange status.
The IRS generally requires investors to identify replacement property within 45 days and complete the exchange within 180 days, or by the applicable tax-return deadline if earlier. Both periods begin when the original property transfers.
A qualified intermediary helps structure the transaction, but using one does not guarantee a successful exchange.
What taxes might apply after a failed 1031 exchange?
When an exchange fails, the sale may trigger federal capital gains tax, depreciation recapture-related tax consequences, and applicable state taxes.
The actual liability depends on the property’s adjusted tax basis, selling expenses, prior depreciation, and the taxpayer’s circumstances.
The following hypothetical comparison shows how a failed exchange can affect gain recognition:
Hypothetical
Assuming no selling expenses or other adjustments, a fully qualifying exchange could defer the $800,000 gain. If the exchange fails, that gain may become taxable. That figure is not the tax bill. The amount ultimately taxable and the applicable rates require a separate calculation.
IRS Publication 544 explains how property dispositions and like-kind exchanges are treated for federal tax purposes.
Key failed exchange terms
- Failed 1031 exchange
- An intended exchange that does not satisfy the requirements for tax deferral.
- Adjusted basis
- A property’s tax basis after applicable adjustments, including depreciation.
- Recognized gain
- Gain taken into account for tax purposes.
- Constructive receipt
- Access or control over funds that may be treated as receipt for tax purposes.
- Depreciation recapture
- Tax treatment that can apply to gain attributable to prior depreciation deductions.
Can investors reduce the risk of exchange failure?
Yes. Early planning can address many preventable problems.
With more than 40 years of commercial real estate experience, I recommend screening replacement properties before the original sale closes. This gives buyers more time to investigate potential problems. These steps can reduce preventable risk:
- Engage a qualified intermediary before the transfer
- Review replacement options early
- Confirm financing feasibility
- Examine tenant strength
- Review lease obligations
- Check title and property condition
When considering NNN real estate for sale, examine tenant strength, lease obligations, title, and property condition before committing. Our guide to evaluating an NNN leased property outlines important checks, and our NNN investment information offers additional guidance.
Key takeaways
- A failed exchange may make the property’s gain taxable.
- Missed deadlines and improper handling of proceeds are common risks.
- The IRS generally allows 45 days for identification and up to 180 days for completion, subject to the tax-return deadline.
- Realized gain is not the same as the amount of tax owed.
A tax deadline should never force an investor into a property that fails basic investment due diligence.
Talk to Our Team
Ready to find your next NNN property?
Reach out and one of our advisors will help you evaluate your options and find the right NNN property.
Triple Net Companies · 1-800-367-7283